arXiv Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/arXiv

arXiv · 0912.0929

Hubble Residuals of Nearby Type Ia Supernovae Are Correlated with Host Galaxy Masses

Patrick L. Kelly·Malcolm Hicken·David L. Burke·Kaisey S. Mandel·Robert P. Kirshner
View original source ↗Read source document ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

From Sloan Digital Sky Survey u'g'r'i'z' imaging, we estimate the stellar masses of the host galaxies of 70 low redshift SN Ia (0.015 < z < 0.08) from the hosts' absolute luminosities and mass-to-light ratios. These nearby SN were discovered largely by searches targeting luminous galaxies, and we find that their host galaxies are substantially more massive than the hosts of SN discovered by the flux-limited Supernova Legacy Survey. Testing four separate light curve fitters, we detect ~2.5σ correlations of Hubble residuals with both host galaxy size and stellar mass, such that SN Ia occurring in physically larger, more massive hosts are ~10% brighter after light curve correction. The Hubble residual is the deviation of the inferred distance modulus to the SN, calculated from its apparent luminosity and light curve properties, away from the expected value at the SN redshift. Marginalizing over linear trends in Hubble residuals with light curve parameters shows that the correlations cannot be attributed to a light curve-dependent calibration error. Combining 180 higher-redshift ESSENCE, SNLS, and HigherZ SN with 30 nearby SN whose host masses are less than 10^10.8 solar masses in a cosmology fit yields 1+w=0.22 +0.152/-0.143, while a combination where the 30 nearby SN instead have host masses greater than 10^10.8 solar masses yields 1+w=-0.03 +0.217/-0.108. Progenitor metallicity, stellar population age, and dust extinction correlate with galaxy mass and may be responsible for these systematic effects. Host galaxy measurements will yield improved distances to SN Ia.

Explore related subjects

astro-ph.CO

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Patrick L. Kelly, Malcolm Hicken, David L. Burke, Kaisey S. Mandel, Robert P. Kirshner. 2010-05-11. Hubble Residuals of Nearby Type Ia Supernovae Are Correlated with Host Galaxy Masses. https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x%2F715%2F2%2F743

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related papers

arXiv2026

Absorption effects in the expanding Universe: spectral transmittance functions of the intergalactic medium for distant sources

We construct two self-consistent analytic approximations to the neutral hydrogen fraction, $x_{\rm HI}(z)$, and the helium ionization fractions, $x_{\rm HeI}(z)$, $x_{\rm HeII}(z)$, and $x_{\rm HeIII}(z)$, that are consistent with current constraints inferred from quasar spectra, galaxy surveys, and CMB polarization measurements. These approximations describe observationally motivated early- and late-reionization scenarios. Using these histories, we analyse the formation of broad absorption troughs in the continuum spectra of high-redshift sources over $1\leq z_{\rm s}\leq15$. We assume that neutral hydrogen and helium in a homogeneous diffuse intergalactic medium reside predominantly in their ground states and absorb radiation through the Lyman-series lines and continua of HI, HeI, and HeII. We compute the wavelength-dependent optical depths for the first 39 Lyman-series lines of HI and HeII, the first 10 lines of HeI, and the corresponding continua, and use them to derive spectral transmittance functions, $T(λ;z_{\rm s})$. As illustrative applications, we apply them to toy-model continuum spectra of starless haloes and to model spectra of a low-metallicity dwarf galaxy at different redshifts. Spectral features in sources at $5\lesssim z_{\rm s}\lesssim7$ caused by intergalactic absorption are found to be particularly sensitive to the adopted hydrogen and helium ionization histories

astro-ph.CO↗
arXiv2026

Union3.1: Reducing Systematics in Supernova Cosmology with Self-consistent Measurements of Host Galaxy Properties for 2000 Type Ia Supernovae

Photometrically derived distances of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) rely on a $\sim5\%$ empirical correction based on host galaxy properties, e.g., global stellar mass. Unbiased cosmology inference therefore requires the self-consistent determination of host properties across the full range of redshifts probed, which we undertake here for approximately 2000 SNe in the Union3 compilation (now Union3.1). We use homogeneous, optical-infrared photometry from the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys to infer global galaxy properties using the stellar population synthesis and SED-fitting code Prospector. We find that the host masses of $z<0.1$ SNe in Union3 were on average overestimated, while the opposite was true for $z<0.15$ SNe in Pantheon+. After correction, the two studies' average distance modulus estimated for low-redshift SNe, previously $>0.03$ mag discrepant, come into 0.01 mag agreement. Updating the UNITY SN analysis, we find the uncertainties on all standardization parameters shrink to $0.6$-$0.9\times$ their previous sizes. For flat-$Λ$CDM, we find from SNe alone $Ω_m=0.344^{+0.026}_{-0.025}$ (a $-0.4σ$ shift from Union3). We then combine with measurements of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and the Cosmic Microwave Background exactly as done by DESI DR2 and find for flat $w_0w_a$CDM, $w_0=-0.719\pm0.084$ and $w_a=-0.95^{+0.29}_{-0.26}$, corresponding to $3.4σ$ evidence against a cosmological constant (down from $3.8σ$ per DESI-DR2+Planck+Union3). Updating the DESI-DR2+Planck+SN combined probe analysis with the recent Dovekie recalibration of DES-SN5YR (B. Popovic et al. 2025) or the updated Pantheon+, we find $3.4σ$ (was $4.2σ$ before Dovekie) and $3.2σ$ (was $2.8σ$ before our correction to Pantheon+) evidence, respectively, against a cosmological constant--a significantly improved consistency between SN analyses.

astro-ph.CO↗
arXiv2026

Reconciling large-scale Lyman-$α$ correlations with the SCRIPT Semi-numerical Model

Recent analyses of high-redshift Lyman-$α$ forest observations have revealed strong correlations on scales exceeding 200 cMpc at redshift z = 6. Reproducing these large-scale correlations has proven challenging for current large-volume reionization simulations. In this work, we investigate these large-scale correlations using mock spectra generated from the extended SCRIPT semi-numerical reionization model. We find that while the fiducial model ensemble systematically predicts smaller correlation lengths than those inferred from the 67 sightlines in the extended XQR-30 sample, 17.5% of individual mock realizations can naturally reproduce the observed signal. Using a delete-2 jackknife analysis, we demonstrate that the observed large-scale correlation length is disproportionately driven by a rare pair of highly transmissive sightlines associated with high-redshift transmission spikes. By inserting two such highly transmissive sightlines into our mock realizations, the fraction of realizations consistent with the observed redshift evolution and correlation length increases significantly from 17.5% to 74.1%. Furthermore, we show that spatial fluctuations in the ionizing mean free path remain an essential physical ingredient for reproducing the observed correlation structure. Our results suggest that the unexpectedly large Lyman-$α$ correlations can be reconciled with existing reionization models when accounting for cosmic variance and the outsized statistical impact of highly transmissive sightlines that occur as prominent outliers within the observational sample.

astro-ph.CO↗